Beyond the To-Do List: The Critical Distinction Between Leadership Accountability and Responsibility

Scroll Down
More Articles
Sally Schmall
Sally Schmall
Head of Executive Leadership Development
March 24, 2025

As an organisational and leadership development consultant, I've seen firsthand the confusion surrounding "responsibility" and "accountability." While often used interchangeably, these terms represent distinct concepts with profound implications for team dynamics and organisational success. Understanding the difference is crucial for fostering a culture of ownership and high performance.

Responsibility: The "What" and "How"

Responsibility typically refers to the duties and tasks assigned to an individual. It's about the "what" and "how" of a job. It’s what most leaders used to be great at as individual contributors.

Accountability: The "Why" and "Outcome"

Accountability, on the other hand, goes beyond task completion. It's about owning the outcome, regardless of who performed the tasks. It's about the "why" and the result.

Bottom line - You can delegate responsibility, but you cannot delegate accountability.

Understanding this distinction is crucial for effective leadership for several reasons:

  1. Fostering a Culture of Ownership: When leaders embrace accountability, they create a culture where individuals take ownership of their work and its impact. This encourages proactive problem-solving and a commitment to achieving shared goals.
  2. Building Trust: Leaders who hold themselves accountable build trust with their teams. Think about a leader you admire. One who had the courage to lean in and lead during tough times. I bet they demonstrated integrity and a commitment to transparency. Even when the message was hard to share or even harder to hear.
  3. Enabling Strategic Alignment: Accountability ensures that individual and team efforts are aligned with the organisation's overall strategic goals. This is something that often remains elusive in organisations.
  4. Enhancing Performance: Accountability drives performance by focusing on results rather than just activities. When individuals are accountable, they are more likely to be invested in achieving success.
  5. Improving Communication and Collaboration: Clear accountability clarifies roles and expectations, reducing ambiguity and fostering effective communication and collaboration across leadership teams and through their respective functions.

Practical Steps for Cultivating Accountability:

  • Clearly Define Expectations: Ensure that everyone (starting with yourself) understands their responsibilities and accountabilities.
  • Establish Measurable Goals: Set clear KPIs and track progress regularly. Peter Drucker’s perspective remains true “You can’t improve what you don’t measure.”
  • Empower Individuals: Give individuals the autonomy and resources they need to succeed. Most people don’t wake up to be mediocre but they cant be amazing without the ability to own something, understand it and have the right resources to make it happen.
  • Provide Regular Feedback: Offer constructive feedback and acknowledge both successes and failures. On the flip side, if you want people to be adaptable and open to feedback, so must you.
  • Hold Individuals Accountable: Address performance issues promptly and fairly. I have never heard a client say, “I sure wish I had waited longer before I addressed that performance issue.”
  • Lead by Example: Leaders must demonstrate accountability in their own actions. Afterall, accountability breeds response-ability.

Photo by Christina @ wocintechchat.com on Unsplash

Back to Journal
Enquire Us
This is some text inside of a div block.
This is some text inside of a div block.

Who to talk to at Five

Sally Schmall
Head of Executive Leadership Development
sally@fivenz.com

Related services

🟤 Strategy & Leadership

Organisational Design

We help you to design new strategies, processes, metrics, ways of working, methodologies, services and structures to deliver your strategic and cultural aspirations.
Our extensive experience, expert guidance and fresh perspectives can help you to quickly pinpoint and address inefficiencies in your organisation, leading to cost savings and improved operations. While there's an initial cost, the long-term benefits and risk reduction make engaging with Five to get your organisation design right a worthy investment.
Learn more
🟤 Strategy & Leadership

Executive Coaching

Resilient leaders deliver results that matter and change that inspires.
Empower your leadership! Our bespoke coaching unlocks your potential, equips you to lead through change, resolve conflicts, and build talent.
Learn more
🟤 Strategy & Leadership

Executive Traction Labs

Transitioning into a new leadership role is the first step. We help you plan out the next 6 months to ensure your success.
Transitioning into a new leadership role is just the beginning. Five is your partner in creating a bespoke leadership Traction Lab to map out the critical first six months to ensure your success. Leadership demands can be intricate and essential to get right, and our labs are co-designed with your organisational leaders and stakeholders to address the specific challenges and priorities crucial to your success. You’ll embark on an immersive, confidential half-day experience, incorporating feedback from key stakeholders and your own insights to create a unique stakeholder and talent engagement plan culminating into a strategic roadmap. By participating, you’ll gain the personalised support and guidance needed for a seamless transition, ensuring resilience, adaptability, and emotional intelligence as you establish yourself as a top-notch leader.
Learn more
❇️ Performance

Performance Advisory & Coaching

Unlock the potential of your teams with performance coaching that drives success.
Unlock the potential of your teams with performance advisory and coaching that drives success. We understand that a strong team is the linchpin of your success, and that's why we offer performance advisory and coaching services tailored to every career stage and tenure. Our approach is grounded in behavioural science, organisational design, and user research, ensuring efforts that lead to visible transformation. Our bespoke offer empowers individuals and teams to identify their strengths, set specific goals, and create actionable plans for success. With ongoing support, feedback, and positive pressure, we propel individuals and teams forward swiftly and seamlessly. Invest in the professional development of your teams through coaching to witness skyrocketing engagement, productivity, and performance, strengthening your organizational culture, reducing turnover, and associated costs, all leading to a measurable return on investment.
Learn more
🟤 Strategy & Leadership

Strategic and Transformation Advisory

We help you to gain valuable insights and fresh perspectives at the executive table, with assessment and challenge of your existing strategies, capabilities, tactics and systems.
Our approach incorporates culture, processes, systems and tools, to create an environment that fosters adaptability and strategic alignment to navigate the rapidly shifting business landscape.
Learn more
🟤 Strategy & Leadership

Transformation

Connect your transformation to your strategy to enable organisational agility
Are you seeking a transformation that seamlessly connects strategy and agile execution while maintaining a laser focus on outcomes? Transformation by Five is your answer. We break down the silos between strategy and execution to ensure your lessons learned from execution inform your future strategic direction. Our approach covers culture, processes, systems, and tools to create an adaptable and strategically aligned environment for navigating the ever-shifting business landscape.
Learn more
Loading
Five logo